More on The “Muslim World” Speech


First of all — many thanks to Henry for stepping in. Second, I want to build on a point he makes about David Frum’s criticism of Obama’s upcoming address in Egypt.

David Frum is absolutely correct to reject the notion of addressing a unified “Muslim World,” especially by elevating Egypt’s political and cultural system as its representative. However, if the President can adeptly navigate the numerous and contradictory elements that have collectively—but not individually—defined the country’s past, he might be able to encourage a more productive dialogue concerning the diverse, and often paradoxical, elements that have similarly shaped the “Muslim World.”

Now, I think the specific argument Henry uses is a fairly convincing one, but I would also add that Frum’s argument is perfectly objectionable in its naive interpretation of the world as composed primarily of clashing ideologies. Certainly, there’s some small element of truth to this, but I think that Bush’s tragically failed efforts at democracy promotion by casting far the light of freedom has shown the limits of this thinking. That is, there’s simply no escaping the geopolitical reality that Egpyt is, as Frum correctly notes, “an important US ally.” It’s true, Egypt is hardly an examplar of social and civil liberty, but the point is that’s what we have to work with. Picking a country whose government and society more closely resemble a Western democracy might more accurately communicate our ideals, but it certainly won’t make Egypt any less strategically vital to US interests. This neoconservative instict to close your eyes, stick your fingers in your ears, and yell “la-la-la-la” does not actually remove thorny issues.

What’s more, delivering a speech in Indonesia won’t make Egypt more like Indonesia. Sure, it offers some marginal — and decidedly unconvincing — enticement for reform, but fails to account for the fact that Indonesia and Egypt have very different geopolitical considerations. Highlighting Indonesia’s more democratic society won’t change the fact that Egypt is in the Persian Gulf geopolitically resembles a Persian Gulf state and Indonesia is in the Pacific Ocean, that they have wildly different economies and interests, and that these facts have shaped their political systems.


One Response to “More on The “Muslim World” Speech”

  1. Pedant Says:

    Sir Jon,

    Not disputing your final comments but rather for the sake of quelling geographic ignorance I must make a minor correction:

    Egypt is bordered by the Mediterranean and the Red Sea. The Persian Gulf (otherwise referred to as the Arab Gulf) is on the far side of the Arabian Peninsula.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: